Disgorgement and prejudgment interest comprise the bulk of SEC recovery in corporate FCPA enforcement actions (typically 90% or so of overall recovery in most years).
However, in approximately 40% of corporate FCPA enforcement actions since 2010 the SEC has assessed a civil monetary penalty.
It is often a mystery (or at least not reasonably transparent) why most corporate FCPA enforcement actions by the SEC do not include a civil penalty, but some do.
In addition, it is often a mystery (or at least not reasonably transparent) how the civil penalties are actually calculated.
The FCPA Guidance (2d Edition) states:
“For violations of the anti-bribery provisions, corporations and other business entities are subject to a civil penalty of up to $21,410 per violation. Individuals, including officers, directors, stockholders, and agents of companies, are similarly subject to a civil penalty of up to $21,410 per violation, which may not be paid by their employer or principal.
For violations of the accounting provisions in district court actions, SEC may obtain a civil penalty not to exceed the greater of (a) the gross amount of the pecuniary gain to the defendant as a result of the violations or (b) a specified dollar limitation. The specified dollar limitations are based on the nature of the violation and potential risk to investors, ranging from $9,639 to $192,768 for an individual and $96,384 to $963,837 for a company. SEC may obtain civil penalties both in actions filed in federal court and in administrative proceedings.”
Regardless of the above issues, set forth below are the Top 25 civil monetary penalties in FCPA actions.
Company | Year | Amount |
1. Goldman Sachs | 2020 | $400 million |
2. MTS | 2019 | $100 million |
3. Credit Suisse | 2020 | $65 million |
4. BHP Billiton | 2015 | $25 million |
5. Hitachi | 2015 | $19 million |
6. ABB | 2010 | $16.5 million |
7. SQM | 2017 | $15 million |
8. Halliburton | 2017 | $14 million |
9. Titan | 2005 | $13 million |
10. Mondelez International | 2017 | $13 million |
11. ABB | 2004 | $10.5 million |
12. Baker Hughes | 2007 | $10 million |
13. Las Vegas Sands | 2016 | $9 million |
14. Eli Lilly | 2012 | $8.7 million |
15. WPP | 2020 | $8 million |
16. Stryker | 2018 | $7.8 million |
17. Qualcomm | 2016 | $7.5 million |
18. Juniper Networks | 2019 | $6.5 million |
19. Biomet | 2017 | $6.5 million |
20. Allianz | 2012 | $5.3 million |
21. Sanofi | 2018 | $5 million |
22. BNY Mellon | 2015 | $5 million |
23. Telefonica Brasil | 2019 | $4.125 million |
24. United Technologies | 2018 | $4.0 million |
25. AB Volvo | 2008 | $4.0 million |